Question
학생이 쓴 원문
I would like to know why the answer " was feeling" is correct grammtically.
3. Diane __has felt______ (feel) very sick but she decided to go out anyway.
was feeling
has been feeling
has felt
>>> was feeling
In my grammatical knowledge, the progressive form cannot be used for the verbs meaning sense, emotion, and possession, etc. Basically, progressive form tense shows that things are keeping going by Will of Subject like "I am seeing a car"(I can stop seeing it whenever I want), therefore, if the verb itself has the meaning of progress, it doesn't need to be expressed with Progressive form in sentences.
For example; The food is tasting bitter(x).
Since the taste of bitterness exists continually regardless of will of the food, the sentence cannot be used in progressive form.
Before I solved the problem No.3. I have studied the theory explained above in Korean and I wrote it in English. Hope my explanation could be conveyed to you well^^.
Regards,
[이름]
강사 첨삭
Hi David!
Indeed, you explained it well and good!
It\'s my bad when I didn\'t check thoroughly my little grammar rules. Your answer \"has felt\" is correct as you\'ve explained to me.
But how about the other one \"was feeling\"? It is correct too.
Let\'s take a look at the sentence, \"Diane was feeling very sick but she decided to go out anyway.\"
We used past progressive tense; Be verb+verb+ing (was+feel+ing).
On the other hand, \"Diane has felt very sick but she decided to go out anyway.\" is also correct because the meaning is the same.
The only difference is that, you used plain past tense.
It was my mistake when I gave you a very vague direction.
Thank you for being a detailed and observant student.
Whew! I felt embarrassed.
Let\'s talk more in class tomorrow.
T. Leny
I would like to know why the answer \" was feeling\" is correct grammatically. >>> CORRECT3. Diane __has felt______ (feel) very sick but she decided to go out anyway.was feelinghas been feelinghas felt>>> was feelingIn my grammatical knowledge, the progressive form cannot be used for the verbs meaning sense, emotion, and possession, etc.
>>> Based on my grammar knowledge, the progressive form of verbs can\'t be used when it means sense, emotion, possession, etc.
Basically, progressive form tense shows that things are keeping going by Will of Subject like \"I am seeing a car\"(I can stop seeing it whenever I want),
>>> Basically, progressive tense of verbs show or describe ongoing actions. For example, \"I am seeing a car.\" (I can\'t stop seeing it whenever I want.)
Therefore, if the verb itself has the meaning of progress, it doesn\'t need to be expressed in progressive form in sentences.
>>> CORRECTFor example; The food is tasting bitter(x).
>>> CORRECTSince the taste of bitterness exists continually regardless of will of the food, the sentence cannot be used in progressive form.>>> CORRECTBefore I solved problem no.3, I have studied the theory explained above in Korean and I wrote it in English.
>>> CORRECT
Hope my explanation could be conveyed to you well^^.
>>> CORRECTRegards,David
>>> CORRECT
파워잉글리쉬 영어첨삭교정 서비스에 실제로 접수된 글입니다. 작성자와 글에 등장하는 사람·회사 이름, 연락처 등 개인을 알아볼 수 있는 정보는 모두 지웠습니다. 문법 오류는 학습 자료로서의 가치를 위해 원문 그대로 두었습니다.